By Laura Ben-David
I have lived in Israel for 17 years, and I have lived in the Gush Etzion region of the West Bank the entire time.
To much of the world, that makes me a settler who lives on illegally occupied land.
The international community considers all Israeli settlements to be illegal under international law, including East Jerusalem, the Golan Heights and the West Bank, known as Judea and Samaria to us Israelis. Some of these areas are places that Jews have lived for centuries or even thousands of years.
These also happen to be areas in which the Palestinians would like to build their future state. Though there has never before been a Palestinian state, many Arabs who refer to themselves as Palestinians live there — many more Arabs than Jews, each of us in our own separate towns and cities, almost exclusively Arab or Jewish.
The question of the settlements has been put back into the news recently with the announcement from Secretary of State Mike Pompeo that the United States will no longer consider Israeli Jewish settlements in the West Bank to be illegal. That announcement was a reversal of four decades of American policy regarding the legality of the settlements.
But in truth, all of this talk about settlements are a distraction from what really matters: not the governments and their stalled peace process, but the people who live on the land.
I am a professional photographer and speaker. Much of my time is spent reaching out to Jews and non-Jews, left-wingers and right-wingers, religious and secular people, sharing a glimpse of Israel through my photography, speeches and articles.
One of my talks is about being an open-minded Jewish “settler” and my interactions with and support of all people, including Palestinians — a crowd-pleaser that truly crosses social lines. While I recently had one synagogue rescind their speaking invitation when they heard the word “settler,” these stories are usually well received.
One of my favorite things to share is my experience taking a special photography class for Israeli and Palestinian women, run by the organization Roots.
Prior to taking the class, it was hard for most of us to imagine interacting with each other in any way at all. In fact, my own friends were extremely concerned about my safety in taking the class. The Palestinian women were reluctant to attend at all.
But once in the class, we suddenly were all just a bunch of women, smiling and posing for each other in the most natural of ways. It was refreshing, and truly encouraging.
Pundits are saying the actions of the U.S. and the reversal of official policy regarding the Jewish settlements will doom potential Israeli-Palestinian peace efforts. I say that’s nonsense. I’m not one to jump to defend anything automatically, but let’s take a step back and look at things rationally.
From 1949 to 1967 — when there were no settlements at all, nor even a single Jew living in that region — the Arab countries were not interested in peace at all, or in a Palestinian state, for that matter. It was only when Israel acquired territory in the Six Day War and started building communities in the land that it suddenly became an issue.
Peace efforts have failed miserably until now. The one thing Oslo accomplished is separating the Israeli and Palestinian people more than ever, geographically and ideologically, and generating animosity and renewed terror.
President Trump didn’t doom the peace process; it was already doomed.
If you truly support peace, it helps if you don’t demonize settlers — or Palestinians. We are both the ones closest to the conflict. Don’t you think we want a solution?
Perhaps we can put the focus back where it belongs: On the people. Saying “the settlements are an obstacle to peace” is and always has been a bogus excuse for terror attacks from extremists operating out of the West Bank and Gaza.
But being open to real conversations from real people — settlers and Palestinians — can be eye-opening and informative. Perhaps even a bit surprising.
Maybe now, we can all roll up our sleeves and get some actual work done.
A native of Monsey, N.Y., Laura Ben-David is a writer, public speaker, marketing consultant and photographer who lives in the Israeli settlement of Tekoa.
This article was provided by the JTA global new source.
More In News
- The veteran lawmaker cites divisive politics among his reasons for stepping down and leaving political life. read more
- Jmore's latest JBiz meet-up event took place Nov. 19 at the Royal Sonesta Harbor Court Hotel, with meaningful networking, delicious food and drinks and featured speaker Rain Pryor. read more
- The Associated’s Insight Israel Forum aims to facilitate thought-provoking and honest discussions about Israel in a civil context over the next year. read more
- Yonatan Winetraub, a co-founder of Israeli nonprofit SpaceIL, talked with attendees at the Jewish National Fund’s annual "Breakfast for Israel in Maryland" event about Israel's fledgling space program and the … read more